Marineli, Filio; Tsoucalas, Gregory; Karamanou, Marianna; Androutsos, George. Annals of Gastroenterology, 2013
What's Hidden on New York City's Forbidden Island?
- 14 min
- 4,239 views
- 180 likes
- 12 comments
4.2K views
Views updated Oct 19, 2026, from YouTube
Where this comes from
7 sources
11 claims
Every claim below links to the sources behind it. Peer-reviewed research and public records come first.
What the film says
-
North Brother Island lies in the East River between the Bronx and Rikers Island; public access is prohibited, and the occasional researcher or journalist visitor is escorted by NYC Parks staff.
-
Mary Mallon was the first person in the U.S. identified as an asymptomatic carrier of Salmonella typhi; George Soper's investigation identified her, and Sara Josephine Baker was sent to obtain samples.
-
Mallon was forcibly quarantined at Riverside Hospital in 1907 and released in 1910 after promising not to cook.
-
Working as 'Mary Brown' at Sloane Maternity Hospital, she was linked to a 1915 outbreak (25 cases, 2 deaths) and returned to the island, where she remained until her death in 1938.
-
By Mallon's death there were over 400 recorded asymptomatic carriers, none detained as long as she was.
-
Typhoid carrier Frederick Moersch infected more people than Mary Mallon, but after a brief detention on North Brother Island he was allowed to live at home, where the state arranged for his rent to be paid.
-
Her biographer was historian Judith Walzer Leavitt.
-
Survivors reported the life preservers were rotten and useless; there had been no fire drill.
-
Slocum was New York City's deadliest single-day loss of life until the September 11 attacks.
-
Photographer Christopher Payne photographed North Brother Island from 2008 to 2013.
-
Black-crowned night herons nested on North Brother Island, monitored from the 1980s, but had stopped nesting there by 2008. The island is now a bird sanctuary.
Sources
Peer-reviewed
Agencies and public records
The New York Times, 1904
Reporting
Dave Mosher. Business Insider, 2018
American Heritage, 1970
Gilbert King. Smithsonian Magazine, 2012
Atlas Obscura
+ 1 more from University of California Press
Hoppe, Trevor. University of California Press, 2020
Book excerpt on the UC Press blog, 9 April 2020. States that Moersch 'infected more people with typhoid fever than Mallon' and that after a brief detention 'the state even arranged for his rent to be paid'.
Reference
University of Pennsylvania Weitzman School of Design, 2015
Get the next story
New films and field notes. No spam.